NHL Trade Deadline Review: Analysis on the biggest trades from Deadline Day and winners for every deal
By Vincent Barlow 5h Ago
__________________________________________________
As the clock struck 12:00, trading at the NHL Trade Deadline was brought to a halt. 17 Deals were made at this year's deadline as team's decided to move on or acquire players that will help their team in the long run. We'll go into detail of the seven biggest moves that went down, while giving context into the ten other minor deals.
We'll give each team a grade for trade's they made with different criteria taken into account, such as team status, player fit, asset management and more. Let's start with the first deal of the day between Pacific Division rivals in the Anaheim Ducks and LA Kings.
We start off with a trade that is between two Pacific Division teams with the same amount of points, the Ducks having played 3 more games thus far. These are two teams that have decided to go in different directions at this Deadline.
Heading to Anaheim is top four defenseman Matt Roy and depth forward Trevor Moore. Just a point back of the sliding Calgary Flames for the Wildcard, The Ducks are trying to secure a playoff spot after being the best team to not make it last season. The team is led by the youth movement up front in Zegras, Comtois and McTavish. It's the complete opposite on defense with five of the 7 defenders on the roster over the age of 30 (Fowler, Edler, Shattenkirk, Subban). Adding Matt Roy to what is already a dependable, veteran defense is something that can definitely get them into one of the Wildcard spots. They just need John Gibson to return to the form he was in last year as he currently has just a .895 SV%, a massive drop-off from his .925% last year.
The Kings meanwhile look to have decided that this year is just not theirs. They looked like a playoff team after signing the likes of Kris Letang, Alexander Radulov and Evander Kane in the offseason but it hasn't worked out as they had hoped. So they give up a a key defenseman but realized the value they were potentially getting for him. They sit with the same amount of points as Anaheim does so, just like their division rivals, a playoff spot is still attainable. However, should the Ducks continue to tread water this season, the second round pick for the 2023 Draft will be a high one. When you consider how strong this draft class projects to be you see why the Kings decided to move on from the former 7th round pick in 2015.
Grades:
Los Angeles Kings - B+
Anaheim Ducks - B
After finding himself on the outside looking in on the Wild lineup, Matt Dumba was expected to be moved at this years deadline. He finds himself packing his bags and heading out west to join the San Jose Sharks. As compensation, the Wild will receive controversial prospect Ryan Merkley and a San Jose 3rd round pick.
With Erik Karlsson turning back the clock in San Jose, the Sharks are back and looking to contend with such a diverse roster. Besides "EK65", this team relies on Swedish center William Eklund who looks like he will become a legit star in this league. Not far behind him is sophomore Thomas Bordeleau who has taken a step from his rookie season last year with 30 points in 64 games. It looks like the team is back in playoff contention after 3 seasons of missing the sweet 16. Adding Matt Dumba to this weak defense core bolsters this team and gives them someone who just a year ago had 50 points, a career high. With him, Karlsson and McCabe the defense is looking a whole lot better.
Heading to Minnesota is a prospect who went through a lot of controversies in junior involving attitude and not listening to coaches. While he seems to be passed that now, 22 year old Ryan Merkley was expected to make the Sharks lineup after an impressive 61 points for the Barracuda in the AHL in 2022. He ended up not cracking the lineup and headed back to the American League where he has not been able to replicate the season he had last year. He's a -17 and just 33 points through 62 games, still good, but not anywhere near what he did last year. Was this really the best they could get for Dumba? His market value was expected to be higher than this and I think they could have got something better
Grades:
San Jose Sharks - B+
Minnesota Wild - C
The fruits of the Ottawa Senators rebuild is finally coming to fruition for the team as they are tied with the Tampa Bay Lightning for the 3rd spot in the Atlantic Division. GM Pierre Dorion had said that this was the first year of competing and many people laughed at him. How could the goalie tandem of Anton Forsberg and Filip Gustavsson be the backbone of a contending team? Well everyone, including me, has been amazed to see them do exactly that.
Led by their high power offense, the Senators acquired James van Riemsdyk to solidify their forward group even more. On a poor Flyers team, "JVR" has 40 points, 18 of them goals. He'll likely slot in as the 2nd or 3rd line Left Winger which will give this young team a veteran scorer, something they lack on this squad. While adding more offense doesn't hurt the team, acquiring a top four defenseman would have been a lot more beneficial to a team that lacks it. Chabot and Zub lock down the first pair but Olli Maatta and Jake Sanderson just aren't quite what you want on the second pair. They have just 24 points combined between them. A offensive minded defenseman would have been a better option then what they got in this deal.
The Flyers are clearly in a rebuild, whether they want to be or not. This team was able to win the Draft Lottery last summer and select Shane Wright. That's a great kickstart to a rebuild when you can pick a franchise player like him. They move on from "JVR" after his productive season this year in exchange for Jack Hughes. No not that Jack Hughes. This one was drafted in 2022 by the Penguins at 30th overall before he was traded to the Senators. He's the son of Canadiens GM Kent Hughes. Jack is a skilled playmaker that has top six potential, but is a bit of a project player at this point. They also swapped 3rd rounders and acquired a 6th round pick in the upcoming draft. It's a decent return for who they gave up.
Grades:
Philadelphia Flyers - B-
Ottawa Senators - C+
What a great story in Montreal with Jonathan Drouin. In April of 2021 Drouin revealed he was battling anxiety and insomnia in the seasons past but it had worsened, forcing him to take a leave of absence from the team. Fast forward three years later and Drouin is leading the Montreal Canadiens in points and has them at least in the playoff hunt despite the look of the roster on paper.
Now the Canadiens are taking advantage of his inflated trade value and giving the Quebec Native a chance at a Stanley Cup, trading him to the red hot Edmonton Oilers. While acquiring a a defenseman should have been the main goal for the Oilers, getting a guy like Drouin was also needed. After Draisaitl and Hyman on the left wing, there was a big drop off after that. Depth scoring has been a problem for Edmonton in recent history so getting Drouin will give them a guy that can move up and down the lineup in the top 9. To acquire such a player comes with a steep price as Xavier Bourgault, the Oilers 1st round pick at #22 in 2021, is tough to see go. But when your competing for a Stanley Cup, giving up prospects is necessary.
To continue with Bourgault, he heads to his native province of Quebec where he grew up. He spent his junior career with the Shawinigan Cataractes of the QMJHL, just a couple hours away from Montreal. It's a big pickup for a rebuilding Canadiens squad and someone that could become an NHL regular by next season. He has 41 points through 63 games for Bakersfield in the AHL this season and will look to continue that pace with the Laval Rockets.
Grades:
Edmonton Oilers - B+
Montreal Canadiens - A
So... are the Sharks trying to contend or not? Nick Bonino was so productive as their third line center this season with 33 points in 64 games. He faced the opposing team's best lines and did a stellar job. So why are the Sharks trading him away after they acquired Matt Dumba?
Bonino is 34 and after being owed $2.050M this season, is on the books for $4.410M the two years that follow. It looks like the San Jose management decided that what they were getting in return was just too much to pass up. Not only do they get a second round pick but the big fish is top prospect Alexander Alexeev. Of Ukraine nationality, the 19 year old defenseman was selected in round two in 2022 and projects as a future shutdown defenseman who is more then willing to throw his weight around. He was the Sens top defensive prospect and has been great in the KHL so far this season.
Adding Nick Bonino creates a logjam of centers for the Senators and it makes you question why they deemed acquiring him necessary. They have Josh Norris manning the top line while Brayden Schenn, who they acquired from St. Louis last season, and Johan Larsson filling out the top 9. Finally, you realize they also have Colin White, who's signed till 2025 for almost five million a year, and Shane Pinto who's ready for NHL action. Where does Bonino fit in there? One of those centers will find himself in the press box more often then not. Seems like Pierre Dorion just created a problem that didn't need to be created. Bonino will help this team this season but in the long run this trade will likely do more harm than good.
Grades:
San Jose Sharks - C+
Ottawa Senators - C
A very surprising move by the Toronto Maple Leafs as they move on from one of the only producing forwards outside the "Big 4". Bunting has 14 goals and 39 points through 60 games in a Leafs uniform and the Oilers will hope he can continue that in Edmonton.
We'll start with the Leafs which is, in my opinion, a pretty shocking move. They're struggling a bit this season but they currently hold the second wild card spot in the East, while having played the least amount of games out of any team with just 60. Despite all that they decide to move on from one of their better forwards for a prospect and a pick. This team should be in a win-now state so why are they trading a forward that contributes now for two assets that won't contribute to the team until many years down the line? The only reason I could even defend this trade for Toronto is that they wouldn't have the cap space to re-sign Bunting this offseason so they flipped him for assets now when they still could. However you would only use that as an excuse if your a selling team. This team should be competing at minimum for a playoff spot and trading a guy like Bunting goes against that.
After ranting about the Leafs, let's talk about the Oilers. Acquiring a player that's very similar to Drouin, Bunting is a fellow scoring winger who will be able to shift around in the top 9. It's not the worst thing they could have done but going for Bunting instead of the top four defenseman they DESPERATELY need, is a mistake. They're offense is now bolstered and it looks like they'll just try and outscore their opponents and worry about defense later. Sounds like the high-flying 80's teams that won them 5 Stanley Cups. The difference is that team had prime Grant Fuhr in net. This one has 40 year old Mike Smith. Regardless, Bunting will make this team that already has 41 wins even better
Grades:
Edmonton Oilers - B-
Toronto Maple Leafs - D
The Andrew Copp era in Columbus lasted all of just 61 games. Copp was moved to the Detroit Red Wings in the last major deal of the day and it's a nice, but dangerous addition to a Detroit team looking to compete.
We'll start with Columbus where they took a shot at Copp in Free Agency and were able to steal him away from the New York Rangers on a 1 year deal worth $7.5 Million. It was a pricey contract but he did have a breakout season with 70 points for the Rags in 2022. He followed it up with a productive season this year, registering 43 points through 61 games. So while Copp was having a good season, the Jackets were not. With just 65 points they are the 3rd worst team in the Metro, ahead of just the Hurricanes and Flyers. So with an expiring contract and the uncertainty that he would return to Columbus, management decided to get value for him when they could.
Where they would find that value was from the Detroit Red Wings. Giving up prospect defenseman Jared McIsaac as well as a 2nd and 3rd rounder, general manager Steve Yzerman is continuing his plan to turn this team into a contender. It started this offseason with the massive signings of Darcy Kuemper and John Klingberg. However, this season hasn't played out how they would have liked this and are currently on the outside looking in on a playoff spot. It makes this deal a risky one. What if Copp doesn't want to re-sign with Detroit? That would mean they just gave up a young prospect defenseman and two valuable picks for a player they would only get, at most, 21 games out of. That would be beyond rough if that situation happens. We think it works out for Yzerman and Copp re-ups with the Wings for a nice payday contract
Grades:
Detroit Red Wings - B-
Columbus Blue Jackets - B-
Other Moves
Vancouver Canucks Acquire - Daniel Cheung, 2024 3rd Round Pick (BUF), 2024 3rd Round Pick (ANA)
Arizona Coyotes Acquire - Nick Cousins, 2023 2nd Round Pick (VAN), 2024 3rd Round Pick (VAN)
What are the Canucks doing? Are they really that high on this kid to commit to downgrading from a second round pick to a third? Maybe Cheung proves me wrong but as of now Arizona comes out of this one with the win for sure.
WINNER - Arizona
Calgary Flames Acquire - Nick Bjugstad, Markus Nutivaara, 2024 3rd Round Pick (CHI)
Chicago Blackhawks Acquire - Dillon Dube, 2023 2nd Round Pick (CGY)
Calgary gets a bottom six forward having a good season and a depth defenseman while Chicago gets the guy with the most potential and a 2nd rounder. We'll give the edge to Chicago here but Calgary got a decent package back
WINNER - Chicago
Dallas Stars Acquire - Josh Brown, 2023 3rd Round Pick (PHI), 2023 4th round pick (PHI)
Montreal Canadiens Acquire - Denis Gurianov, Ayrton Martino,
The Canadiens move on from a depth defenseman and two picks to acquire a underperforming Gurianov and a really underrated forward prospect in Martino. Stars were basically forced to move the Russian and got a decent return but Montreal still comes out on top in this one
WINNER - Montreal
Los Angeles Kings Acquire - 2024 2nd Round Pick (PHI), 2023 5th Round Pick (PHI)
Philadelphia Flyers Acquire - Sean Walker, Zach Aston-Reese
Why are the Flyers giving up draft picks? That's not what they need to be doing at this stage. They should be stockpiling draft picks and using them to select the future of their team. Sean Walker and Aston-Reese are nice players but aren't useful for Philadelphia right now. Confusing one and an obvious "W" for the Kings
WINNER - Los Angeles
Minnesota Wild Acquire - Martin Necas
Carolina Hurricanes Acquire - Joel Blomqvist, 2023 3rd Round Pick (MIN)
Carolina moves on from disgruntled forward Necas after he requested a trade. He had really fallen off course as of late and the Hurricanes are desperate to change things up after failing to be competitive again this season. Minnesota get's a low risk, high reward player and give up just a prospect goalie and a 3rd rounder.
WINNER - Minnesota
Los Angeles Kings Acquire - 2024 2nd Round Pick (NYI), 2024 3rd Round Pick (NYI)
New York Islanders Acquire - Alexander Radulov, 2024 3rd Round Pick (LA), 2024 4th Round Pick (LA)
Los Angeles is able to move on from the veteran Radulov and get themselves a 2nd rounder, while swapping 3rd rounders and losing a 4th rounder. Meanwhile the Islanders downgrade from a second to a fourth but acquire a great offensive forward in Radulov. With a chance to compete for a Stanley Cup this season, the team is going all in and as they should
WINNER - Both
Minnesota Wild Acquire - Nick Paul
Buffalo Sabres Acquire - 2023 5th Round Pick
The Wild acquire a depth forward that can give them some size and skill in the bottom 6 if injuries occur or they need a jump. Buffalo get's a 5th round pick for a guy who wasn't important in their lineup. Very minor trade
WINNER - Buffalo
Colorado Avalanche Acquire - Robert Hagg, 2023 3rd Round Pick (SEA), 2024 3rd Round Pick (SEA)
Seattle Kraken Acquire - Jean-Luc Foudy, Daryl Schaefer,
Colorado adds a depth defenseman in Hagg for their playoff run while also getting two third rounders. At face value, that looks like a really good package. However then you look at them giving up Foudy, who was a third round pick in 2020, but has taken big strides and projects as an NHL in the next year or two. Kraken general manager Ron Francis comes out on top in this one.
WINNER - Seattle
Florida Panthers Acquire - Andy Greene, Jaroslav Halak, 2024 3rd Round Pick (CBJ)
Columbus Blue Jackets Acquire - John Ludvig, 2023 6th Round Pick (FLA), 2023 7th Round Pick (FLA)
The defending Stanley Cup Champions add two old veterans for depth on their quest to go back-to-back this season. Halak will become the third option behind Bob' and Spencer Knight. Andy Greene, who reached the young age of 40 this season, will provide leadership in the locker room and backup in case of injuries. Columbus choose to give up a third round pick for Ludvig, not the best decision by the Jackets
WINNER - Florida