FIFA 17 Simulation Sliders

[ricardodc]

06/10/2016 test #2:

Morecambe (1*) vs Man Utd (5*)
15 min halves
CPU vs CPU
Default sliders

LEGENDARY
Goals 1-2
Shots 5-11
Shots on target 2-6
Possession% 42-58
Tackles 20-15
Fouls 1-3
Injuries 0-2
Offsides 1-0
Corners 1-6
Shot accuracy% 40-54
Pass accuracy% 84-90

WORLD CLASS
Goals 1-5
Shots 2-18
Shots on target 2-13
Possession% 42-58
Tackles 22-17
Fouls 4-2
Injuries 0-0
Offsides 0-1
Corners 2-4
Shot accuracy% 100-72
Pass accuracy% 80-90

PROFESSIONAL
Goals 0-7
Shots 4-22
Shots on target 1-16
Possession% 40-60
Tackles 13-23
Fouls 0-2
Injuries 0-0
Offsides 0-0
Corners 2-8
Shot accuracy% 25-72
Pass accuracy% 88-92

Comments: It's starting to look obvious that Legendary doesn't deliver the most realistic stats/scores. It's the most challenging but does that by even all teams strengths. That's not what I am looking for.

[The Old Dane]

Quote: Originally Posted by ricardodc

Hi mate! What a surprise! Ok. I won't ask... I know it's not a convencional aprouch but I am willing to take the chance and see where it goes. I believe by just playing CPU vs CPU it will show the differences in gameplay in those difficulty levels. The advantage is that the user ability factor is not a variable. I just played one game and already noticed some differences. I expect the next tests to confirm my suspicious. I am aware I might be alone on this task but I don't mind. Of course it would be great to have help but I understand that people want the work done and to just test the set. Cheers! Enviado do meu GT-I8190 através de Tapatalk

As I said, your idea is exciting and ambitious. I will continue to support you, even though I have a different approach, which as you know I can do somewhere else. But I know you, and can look at the matches you have selected that you look at the game's team ID is different - you've found it ?.
Cheers mate

[ohvitser12]

These cpu vs cpu matches are much more real life like on world class difficulty as it seems.The stats seem to be much more logical.

[ricardodc]

Quote: Originally Posted by asdrubale71

we ask only to have a real setting for the matches....nothing else......i'm a fan of exibithion games and i use to simulate champions league, serie a, europa league matching cpu vs cpu and i'm looking for a real settings

Have you played CPU vs CPU? What difficulty level? What do you think needs to be adjusted to look more realistic? (speed? pass speed or error? lines? etc)

Quote: Originally Posted by The Old Dane

As I said, your idea is exciting and ambitious. I will continue to support you, even though I have a different approach, which as you know I can do somewhere else. But I know you, and can look at the matches you have selected that you look at the game's team ID is different - you've found it ?. Cheers mate

As soon as I choose the difficulty level I will also post "somewhere else". Like I said, it's obvious that Legendary makes teams look more alike and every team will be though to defeat. That's fine when you play even teams but when you face uneven teams that's not realistic. Also, I see more gameplay variety in lower difficulty levels. I think it's because error is more acceptable and so players will take more risks.

Quote: Originally Posted by ohvitser12

These cpu vs cpu matches are much more real life like on world class difficulty as it seems.The stats seem to be much more logical.

After only 2 tests looks like WC and Professional deliver the most realistic stats/scores. I will continue the testing by rising the weaker side strength.

Cheers!

[ricardodc]

06/10/2016 test #3:

Chesterfield (2*) vs Chelsea (5*)
15 min halves
CPU vs CPU
Default sliders

LEGENDARY
Goals 1-2
Shots 10-16
Shots on target 5-10
Possession% 46-54
Tackles 13-31
Fouls 1-6
Injuries 2-0
Offsides 0-0
Corners 4-7
Shot accuracy% 50-62
Pass accuracy% 91-87

WORLD CLASS
Goals 1-1
Shots 5-16
Shots on target 3-10
Possession% 51-49
Tackles 16-23
Fouls 3-0
Injuries 1-1
Offsides 0-1
Corners 1-3
Shot accuracy% 60-62
Pass accuracy% 92-88

PROFESSIONAL
Goals 0-3
Shots 6-16
Shots on target 1-9
Possession% 54-46
Tackles 10-33
Fouls 1-1
Injuries 1-0
Offsides 0-4
Corners 2-1
Shot accuracy% 16-56
Pass accuracy% 93-86

Comments: Professional wins on most realistic scores/shots. Possession% reflects Chelsea tactics and being on the winning side soon in the game. Pass accuracy is off for every difficulty level.

[The Old Dane]

Yes, i think you right about legendary. Right now i play cpu/cpu SonderjydskE vs Bayern 15 min legend. After 43 min 1-1, you gotta be joking!. More later...

[ohvitser12]

Quote: Originally Posted by ricardodc

06/10/2016 test #3: Chesterfield (2*) vs Chelsea (5*) 15 min halves CPU vs CPU Default sliders LEGENDARY Goals 1-2 Shots 10-16 Shots on target 5-10 Possession% 46-54 Tackles 13-31 Fouls 1-6 Injuries 2-0 Offsides 0-0 Corners 4-7 Shot accuracy% 50-62 Pass accuracy% 91-87 WORLD CLASS Goals 1-1 Shots 5-16 Shots on target 3-10 Possession% 51-49 Tackles 16-23 Fouls 3-0 Injuries 1-1 Offsides 0-1 Corners 1-3 Shot accuracy% 60-62 Pass accuracy% 92-88 PROFESSIONAL Goals - Shots - Shots on target - Possession% - Tackles - Fouls - Injuries - Offsides - Corners - Shot accuracy% - Pass accuracy% - Comments: ...

This is really off imho...No way will chesterfield every hold the possesion advantage over Chelsea...shows you that fifa gameplay engine really needs a overhaul i think..Not a big difference between really good and bad teams.That score might happe in real life ,but those posseion and passing accuracy stats are so so wrong

[ricardodc]

06/10/2016 test #4:

Preston (3*) vs Leicester (4,5*)
15 min halves
CPU vs CPU
Default sliders

LEGENDARY
Goals 0-2
Shots 16-11
Shots on target 6-7
Possession% 52-48
Tackles 20-14
Fouls 2-3
Injuries 0-1
Offsides 1-2
Corners 3-1
Shot accuracy% 37-63
Pass accuracy% 89-87

WORLD CLASS
Goals 1-2
Shots 10-10
Shots on target 2-4
Possession% 51-49
Tackles 31-22
Fouls 4-3
Injuries 0-1
Offsides 2-1
Corners 5-0
Shot accuracy% 20-40
Pass accuracy% 87-91

PROFESSIONAL
Goals 3-5
Shots 15-17
Shots on target 6-12
Possession% 49-51
Tackles 23-19
Fouls 2-1
Injuries 1-0
Offsides 1-0
Corners 7-9
Shot accuracy% 40-70
Pass accuracy% 86-89

Comments: I will take Legendary off for further testings. Remain WC and Professional.