I'm getting the game, but I have to agree with your points.
I was hoping the videos released a while back showcased an early build of players that 2K would change later, but the video ends that hope. Medvedev's player model, shown last week, looks good....while Federer's player model, shown around the time of the official announcement, looks pretty bad and like a Fortnight version of the actor Tim DeKay from
White Collar.
I know this sounds nitpicky and petty, but although you could tell the MLB The Show 24 gameplay videos before release were
rehearsed, this game developer video was straight up
scripted--no passion, just robotic reading. They didn't have to scream like Stephen A. Smith, but get enthusiastic about your game.