This is such a great thread. I wanted to add to it since I’m much older (47). My first baseball game I remember was RealSports Baseball for the Atari 2600. My brother got it. It wasn’t a great game at all but it was still cool to see a field with all the position players. However, its controls were a mess.
Then when the NES came and renting games became a thing we rented RBI baseball and had all the real players. Nevertheless, that wasn’t the game that defined my love for baseball games. No, that would be the original Bases Loaded. That game had the best graphics for the time and was fun. It was a huge game in our neighborhood.
Once we made the move to Sega Genesis, I tired Sports Talk Baseball and loved it. But LaRussa Baseball (which changed to MLBPA Baseball in a future edition after LaRussa 95 I think. In addition, eventually Triple Play), Hardball and RBI’s 16 bit efforts all got a spin. However, once World Series Baseball came out, I was hooked. World Series became my first annual purchase.
Then once the PS1 came on the scene, we got into the golden era of baseball video games. Triple Play got really good (before it became too arcade) but VR Baseball was a personal favorite for me. I know some that didn’t care for it but I was a fan. High Heat kept coming on strong and Sony got rolling with the MLB series. We finally started to see what baseball video games could be.
I never was into the N64 so there is no Ken Griffey baseball love from me but it deserves a mention due to how loved that game is. I have friends that swore by that title.
Of course, as we got into PS2, the era started very strong. All Star Baseball become of my go to games every year. Sega had World Series back. MLB Slugfest was a fun arcade title. Sony was still kicking with MLB until the 2006 version added the “the Show name. In addition, of course, after Triple Play went too arcade for most, EA returned with the MVP series that made huge improvements and made one of the best baseball games ever in MVP 2005.
Then the NFL decided to sell an exclusive rights agreement to EA for NFL video games. This made MLB offer one for third party manufacturers. (First parties like Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo could still make MLB licensed games.) Sega having lost their NFL game won the MLB third party rights. This meant no more All Star Baseball, no more MVP, and no Slugfest. We were done to two MLB games.
EA kept the MVP series going for two more years with MLB NCAA Baseball, which both were underrated titles, but we only had two MLB options now, Sega’s Major League Baseball 2K or MLB the Show. This was even worse if you had an Xbox because there was only one game in town.
The move to next gen saw Xbox 360 owners stuck with Sega’s offerings, which started off ok, but once they got bugger and even one year launched with bug that wouldn’t allow you advance your game until they released a patch a month or so later. Still, it was an ok game. Moreover, 2K8 introduced analog pitching that I thought would keep me with the series. However, a funny thing happened just a short time later.
I finally got a PS3 to play the new Metal Gear Solid 4 and I decided to get the Show just to try it out. I was blown away. Commentary was on point. The game was hard but solid. It was an amazing game. I have been with The Show ever since. It saved me from a few years of terrible Sega released titles.
This title appeared to be listening to its fan base. They added things like the Rule 5 Draft. And they worked on updating stadiums and Sounds of the Show was amazing and still missed to this day.
The Show has had some issues in recent years but nothing that has made me not want to pick it up. My love for baseball games runs really deep. And this title has really helped get me a great fix. (Just keep working on improving Franchise after a few years off from making it a focus.)